NEW Too Faced Peaches and Cream Matte Palette • Swatches and Review

Too Faced Peaches and Cream Swatches Too Faced Peaches and Cream Review

Just Peachy Mattes Palette Overview

Too Faced just released their NEW Peaches and Cream Collection. It’s beautiful! You can see my video review below. I wanted to supplement it with swatches of the Peaches and cream matte palette to help you decide if you need this warm Just Peachy matte palette in your eyeshadow palette collection. As a woman over 40, I think it’s a lovely addition to my makeup collection. I’ve included swatches below I hope you find helpful.
Overall, I think this Peaches and Cream matte palette itself is lovely and has a nice variety of warm shades. I’m impressed with the quality and the blendability of the Just Peachy Mattes palette.

I thought it would be a good idea to see what shades in other palettes the Just Peachy Mattes shades would be slightly similar to or coordinate with really well. Dislaimer: I don’t have every single Too Faced Palette. But this may help some of you that have the palettes I have. I’ll be swatching and talking about Sweet Peach, Semi-Sweet Chocolate Bar, and Natural Eyes. I’ll also mention some shades in the Natural Mattes palette because I have it here but am keeping it unblemished for a giveaway.

If this helps some of you decide whether or not Just Peachy Mattes is worth the splurge or not, this was worth it! First I’ll show you the swatches themselves…

Ebates Coupons and Cash Back

Too Faced Just Peachy Palette
Too Faced Just Peachy Palette
Too Faced Just Peachy Matte Swatches Too Faced Peach Palette Swatches
Peaches and Cream, Fresh Picked, Peach Sangria, Chocolate Dipped
Too Faced Just Peachy Matte Swatches Too Faced Peach Palette Swatches
Peach Butter, Just Peachy, Peach Punch, Just Ripe
Too Faced Just Peachy Matte Swatches Too Faced Peach Palette Swatches
Peach Meringue, Peach Tea, Peach Cobbler, Peach Tart

My local Sephora had most of the new Too Faced Peaches and Cream Collection. I was able to get some swatches together for you so I could review and give my thoughts on what I could get my hands on. Unfortunately, they only had four of the most unflattering lipstick shades for me. I love the packaging but hated the shades. So those will have to wait.

Peach Meringue

Peach Meringue is a light matte creamy shade that I find easily dupable across palettes. On the eye, one wouldn’t be able to discern much of a difference in an eye look. The top two are the most similar, while Coconut Creme at the bottom is slightly whiter and has a slight sheen to it.

Too Faced Just Peachy Mattes Swatches Too Faced Peach Meringue Swatches
L: Peach Meringue
TOP TO BOTTOM: White Peach (Sweet Peach), Heaven (Natural Matte & Natural Eyes), Coconut Creme (SS Choc Bar)

Peach Tart

Peach Tart is a beautiful warm brown. I didn’t find a true Peach Tart dupe among my palettes, but swatched shades that were similar in intensity to show you those among the palettes. The most similar among the shades was Truffled in Sweet Peach, but both Sweet Peach shades were slightly cooler than Peach Tart

Too Faced Just Peachy Matte Swatches Too Faced Peach Tart Swatches Too Faced Summer Yum Swatches Too Faced Charmed I'm Sure Swatches Too Faced Truffled Swatches Too Faced Cocoa Chili Swatches
TOP: Peach Tart
BOTTOM L-R: Summer Yum, Charmed, I’m Sure, Truffled, Cocoa Chili (all Sweet Peach)

Just Peachy

Just Peachy is a gorgeous shade and again, seems to be undupable among the palettes I own. I feel like this is the shade I was looking for in the original Sweet Peach Palette and I finally got it in Just Peachy Mattes! It’s not too soft, not too bright. It’s the Goldilocks of flattering peachy shadows! Candied Peach is much brighter, Georgia is much softer and lighter. Just Peachy in Sweet Peach isn’t even close to the same shade!

Too Faced Just Peachy Matte Swatches Too Faced Just Peachy Swatches Too Faced Candied Peach Swatches Too Faced Georgia Swatches
TOP: Just Peachy
BOTTOM L-R: Candied Peach, Just Peachy, Georgia (all Sweet Peach)

Just Ripe • Peach Punch • Peach Sangria

I grouped these by intensity and coordinating shades. I started playing around with other Sweet Peach shades and threw in a bit of lagniappe! Though Peach Sangria looks deeper in the pan, it just doesn’t have the color payoff it appears to have. This is the one shade I was disappointed with out of the entire palette. Maybe it’s just my palette, but I find that Peach Sangria is really sheer and has quite a bit of kickup. It took quite a bit of swiping for me to get this swatch. Ca

Candied Peach is the closest to Just Ripe, though less intense and bright. Peach Pit and Delectable have more purple tone to them and much more color payoff than Peach Sangria (which is more wine/plum in tone as the name implies). I just threw Bellini and Just Peachy from Semi Sweet in for fun because they play off these shades so well!

Too Faced Just Peachy Matte Swatches Too Faced Peach Punch Swatches Too Faced Peach Sangria Swatches Too Faced Just Ripe Swatches
TOP L-R: Just Ripe, Peach Punch
MIDDLE: Peach Sangria
BOTTOM L-R: Peach Pit, Delectable, Just Peachy, Candied Peach, Bellini (all Sweet Peach)

Peach Cobbler • Peach Tea • Fresh Picked

I don’t feel like any of these are truly similar but you may be able to create a similar look using Peanut Butter and Peach Cobbler. I do love the warmth of both Peach Cobbler and Peach Tea and the mix of the peachy brown tones in Fresh Picked.

Too Faced Just Peachy Matte Swatches Too Faced Peach Cobbler Swatches Too Faced Peach Tea Swatches Too Faced Fresh Picked Swatches
MIDDLE: Fresh Picked
FAR RIGHT TOP TO BOTTOM: Puree (Sweet Peach) Peanut Butter (SS Choc Bar)

Peaches & Cream • Peach Butter

Oddly enough, Peach Butter and Peaches and Cream from Sweet Peach are very similar. But Peaches and Cream isn’t similar to Peaches and Cream from Sweet Peach. Though, light enough for lid, transition or washes of color, these are all a tad bit different.

Too Faced Just Peachy Matte Swatches Too Faced Peaches and Cream Swatches Too Faced Peach Butter Swatches
TOP: Peaches & Creme, Peach Butter.
BOTTOM: Georgia, Peaches & Creme (Sweet Peach), Silk Teddy (Natural Eyes), Nougat (SS Choc Bar)
Too Faced Chocolate Dipped Swatches Too Faced Charmed I'm Sure Swatches Too Faced Sexpresso Swatches Too Faced Hot Fudge Swatches
TOP: Chocolate Dipped
BOTTOM L-R: Charmed, I’m Sure (Sweet Peach), Sexpresso (Natural Mattes, Natural Eyes), Hot Fudge (Sweet Peach)

Final Thoughts

I’ve really been enjoying Just Peachy Mattes and the new Peaches and Cream collection overall. This palette is a Sephora exclusive that retails for $45 USD and can be found at and on You can see my thoughts on the pieces I purchased from the Too Faced Peaches and Cream collection in my video review here:

too faced peaches and cream collection review and swatches



  1. Jean Parcks
    April 5, 2024 / 2:39 am

    Wow, “Just Peachy” sounds like an absolute gem in your collection! It’s great to hear that it stands out and fills a gap that you felt was missing from the original Sweet Peach Palette. Finding the perfect peach shade balance can be quite the journey, but it looks like you’ve finally discovered your Golden Hair shade with Just Peachy Mattes. By the way, I am a student and quite often I turn to for help. Сustom dissertation writing can always be there if you need it. It’s always nice when a palette offers a shade that’s truly unique and irreplaceable. Your comparison to other shades like Candied Peach and Georgia really highlights its difference. Happy mixing and experimenting with your new favorite shade!

  2. March 28, 2024 / 5:08 am

    The way you described the scent of the products has me practically drooling—I’m a sucker for anything peach-scented! Your blog is always my first stop when I’m looking for honest reviews and recommendations, and you never disappoint.

  3. Arlet Amiri
    March 11, 2024 / 8:03 am

    The yeah yeah yeahs sweater noel fielding is a must-have for any fashionista seeking to incorporate a whimsical touch into their wardrobe, thanks to its unique design and vibrant color scheme. Thanks for this great thoughts and facts

  4. Marta
    November 4, 2017 / 10:14 am

    The review I was waiting for! Comparison with the sweetpeach palette wich I love..can’t wait to see in italian Sephora all the collection… thank you beautiful blog, new follower! ?

    • Stephanie Marie
      November 7, 2017 / 8:23 am

      Thank you so much Marta! 🙂

  5. Susieqkw
    September 4, 2017 / 3:37 am

    This looks so pretty and up my alley! I love that they are bringing back all the warm peachy shades again. Back in the day I wore similar shades, sometimes even using my peach blush as shadow and got so many compliments. If only I still had that flawless 20 something skin again, lol. Heading over to YT to watch your review. Have a great morning, Steph:)

    • Stephanie Marie
      September 12, 2017 / 11:57 am

      Thanks! Enjoy your day!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may also enjoy